Post and Page Titles Not Showing Correctly All in One SEO Pack Troubleshooting Forum

Hello. This is very strange – I hope someone out there can help. The site is http://HawaiiHousingNews.com

Post Title Format field and the resulting post titles:
1. %post_title% | %blog_title% –> This ONLY shows the "| blog title" ("| Hawaii Housing News"). Post title is ignored.
2. %post_title% –> URL of post page
3. [blank] –> URL of post page

Now if I manually go to each post and fill in the Title field for the All in One section below the post, then it will be fine, but I don't want to have to do that for every post. It seems to me that %post_title% is being knocked out by the plugin. Shouldn't it just be whatever the title is right above the text of the post itself?

FYI, the same is true for Pages. I have to manually enter in the page name in the AIO Title field or else it just shows "| blog title".

Strangely, though, categories are working fine, properly posting as "Category name | blog name".

Any ideas??